It is cookie season!
Every sugar cookie starts out exactly the same; same dough, same cutter, same shape. What happens after that is where things get interesting, the icing, the colors, the details, all decided one cookie at a time depending on who it is for.
Early in my career, I worked with teenagers in residential care, kids who had been through more than most adults ever will. One of them had frequent outbursts, and the program I worked for at the time had one rule for every kid, ignore the negative behavior and redirect toward something positive. It made sense in theory. For her, it changed nothing.
One day she asked me directly why I was not sending her to her room the way she saw other kids get punished on television. That question stopped me. For most kids, being sent to their room is a punishment. For her, it would have meant something completely different. It would have meant she was being treated like a normal kid, something she had rarely gotten to feel.
Why This Matters for Choosing a Coach
Once we understood what that consequence actually meant to her, we built a plan around it, and it worked. The lesson I carry from that, and the one that matters right now more than ever, is that a strategy is not good or bad on its own. It only works if it fits the brain and the history of the specific child in front of you.
This matters because executive function coaching has become much more popular, and more people than ever are offering it. That growth is genuinely a good thing. More families are getting the support they need. But it also means not every coach is doing the same depth of work, even when the offerings look similar on the surface.
What Good Coaching Actually Looks Like
A planner can transform one child’s homework routine, and become one more thing to lose for another. Breaking an assignment into smaller steps helps a student who needs structure, but it overwhelms a student who could not get started in the first place. None of these strategies are wrong. They are just not universal.
A coach who understands this starts by figuring out what is actually happening for your child, not by handing over a system that worked for someone else’s kid. That takes more than good intentions. It takes understanding how your child’s brain works, what is driving a behavior or a block, and being willing to change course when something is not landing.
Questions Worth Asking
Before choosing a coach for your child, a few questions can tell you a lot.
Does this coach ask questions and get to know your child before recommending strategies? Or do they start with a system on day one, the same one they use with every student?
Can they explain why a particular strategy might work for your child specifically, based on what they have learned about how your child thinks and works, not just because it is generally considered a good strategy?
Are they willing to adjust the plan if it is not working, rather than telling your child they just need to try harder using the same approach?
Do they talk about your child’s strengths as well as their challenges, or only the challenges?
What Changes When You Ask These Questions
The goal is never to find a coach who knows every strategy in existence. The goal is to find a coach who takes the time to understand the brain in front of them before deciding what that brain actually needs. That is the difference between a cookie cutter approach and one that is truly built for your child.
Executive Function Coaching at CPC
At Connected Pathways Coaching, we start with the foundation. We look at the whole picture of how your child’s unique brain works, then build the skills underneath through consistent practice and support. I would love to talk with you about where your child is right now and how we can help them going forward.

